|
|
|
Some of the Ctrl+Atl+Digit combos were interfering with brackets on European keyboards (accidentally triggering the render features when typing "{ [ ] }" ).
As a linux user, this just bit me hard a couple hours ago.
Could stuff that absolutely requires a hotkey (like show UI does) be moved out of the ctrl-alt f-key range? This is a shortcut to a menu option.
So the thing to do is to look at the menu item, that this is a shortcut for. Then you see that it has been changed. So is this a bug? Or should there be bug like 'shortcut changed without mention in Release Notes'? Benja, the problem is that it's been changed to a combo on Linux that does something else - and does it with a higher priority.
Ctrl-Alt-F1 changes to the first virtual terminal, while X (and therefore SL) usually run on VT6 or 7, depending on the distribution. And because you've disabled the GUI, you have no way to re-enable it on Linux without killing the SL process and restarting SL. I confirm this issue as a bug.
You can't Hide/Show UI using UI (actually, you can't Show it back - since you do not know where to click), it would be pretty easy to solve it by choosing a different shortkey. Machinima making and the whole SL experience would be improved (for Linux users) by re-enabling Hide/Show UI. VWR-2896 would probably solve / provide a workaround for this bug, as Linux users would be able to change the shortcut themselves.
I managed to change this shortcut from CTRL ALT F1 to CTRL F1 recompiling the client from sources.
This is not the best solution, since many people still use CTRL F1 in their desktop environment shortcuts - but usually you can easily change/remove it, while I couldn't change CTRL ALT F1. In linden/indra/newview/llviewermenu.cpp , I changed TO sub_menu->append(new LLMenuItemCheckGL("UI", FROM: sub_menu->append(new LLMenuItemCheckGL("UI", I am not a developer and unfortunately I do not know how to make/submit a patch. Note: Common get the CTRL+ALT+F1 WORKING AGAIN hide show UI
I NEED TO MAKE MOVIES IN WINDLIGHT groan - this is so important for people in SL to get right it should be the first thing you do before messing with the sky even :\ fingers crossed you sort it in the next release Moved invalid LLID to description
CTRL-ALT-F1 kills my entire GUI because it shuts down the whole graphics system and goes back to text mode.
Recompiling from source is not exactly a work-around. I am trying to make a machinima ... and If I hide the UI using the menu I have to kill SL and restart to get the menu back. THIS IS CRITICAL FOR LINUX USERS!!!!!! here's a diff that shows how to solve this issue.
the new shortcuts provided here is CTRL ALT 1 instead of CTRL ALT F1. (first, the new proposed version; then, the old version that the official client is featuring right now) diff indra/newview/llviewermenu.cpp indra/newview/llviewermenu.cpp.orig 1296c1296 Opensource Obscure:
diff indra/newview/llviewermenu.cpp indra/newview/llviewermenu.cpp.orig Can you explain what all that means and how to use it? This means that to get from the file newview/llviewermenu.cpp (in the indra/newview directory of the source code) to the file llviewermenu.cpp.orig (in the same directory), you have to replace '1' with KEY-F1 at line 1296. To get from the .orig (probably the original as distributed by Linden Lab) file to the other one (Opensource Obscure's modified version) just reverse that replacement. Then (re)compile the viewer.
Compiling SecondLife from source isn't trivial, but should get easier in the future. Since then, refer to the page for your OS linked at http://wiki.secondlife.com/wiki/Get_source_and_compile#Compiling Like Boroondas Gupte said (thanks for explaining it).
PLEASE NOTE though that you have to replace KEY-F1 with '1' at line 1296 in llviewermenu.cpp - not viceversa. I edited my previous comment - I apologize for not being clear. Right now, compiling the SL viewer from source on Linux is really painful. As Boroondas Gupte said, this should get easier in the future. I see two methods of solving this:
1. Longer term. Convert the advanced menu to XML and maintain a separate menu_viewer.xml for macs and linux. This would be fantastic, and a real benefit to we tinkerers. Longer development time, though. 2. Short term. Create new set of shortcuts. Anyone have any recommendations for ones that'll work on all systems (linux/mac/windows)? I'll attach a patch if someone can give me a good list, but I don't have a linux box right now to test them under. I just enabled 'Patch attached' for this issue (even if actually no real patch files are attached) because this problem can be solved by changing the shortcut from CTRL ALT F1 to CTRL ALT 1, and this is a trivial change.
AFAIK, this new shortcut doesn't interfere with existing shortcuts on Linux and Windows - I couldn't test it on Mac OS X.
Attached patch as described by Opensource Obscure. Untested because I've got build problems (unrelated to this patch).
Patch is against revision 1122 of http://svn.secondlife.com/svn/linden/trunk  Editing and compiling source code to make Opensource Obscure's "trivial change" is not trivial for this Linux user. I'm using Ubuntu, not Gentoo! The core of the problem is that hard-coded function keys should be avoided when you are trying to make an OS-agnostic, global application. Nefertiti, that's why the long term solution to this will hopefully be VWR-2896 (vote it up!)
I guess Opensource's use of the term "trivial" was referring to the small impact his change has on the source*), not how easy or difficult the build process is. Building SL on Gentoo isn't any easier than on Ubuntu, by the way. *) Exchanging a single constant with a single literal – as opposed to VWR-2896, with patches adding more than 3000 lines in total. We're debating what the right way of doing this is. We really would like to avoid ctrl-alt-1 if at all possible, since we're afraid using that key combo may cause problems with i18n character entry. Can someone float this on the sl-ux mailing list?
https://lists.secondlife.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sl-ux Ctrl Alt 1 conflicts in Icewm, lightweight window manager and handy for video capture. Attaching a patch that changes the Ctrl Alt F* series to Ctrl Shift F*. No conflicts found in KDE or Icewm for these. Other DE's and WM"s need to be tested as well as Windows and Mac.
"Reload personal setting overrides" was already using CTRL SHIFT F2, so I changed it to CTRL SHIFT F10 in my patch (see the slviewer-0-v12160-LinuxShortcuts.patch.bz2 attached file).
Ok sorry i really thought that series was clean. But i hope changing that little stray one wouldnt hurt.
Ok, ive been doing some work on these shortcut issues, i found a couple things.
Any Ctrl ALT combination is already used by X or some window managers, also true on mac and was only reported there. The only things left are Ctrl Shift Fn and Alt Shift n. Perfect to wipe out both these issues. So i propose these changes. Features menu options move to Ctrl Shift Fn. As for the weird Particles one the = does not toggle it for some reason, i moved it to ` as a temporary solution. There probably isn't a best way to do this but someone has to make a decision, and some of these items probably should be moved around. Posting this on VWR-9966, VWR-2085 > As for the weird Particles one the = does not toggle it for some reason,
> i moved it to ` as a temporary solution. note that ` is not available on some keyboard layouts as a single-stroke key - you have to press Alt-Gr ' to print that character. Hopefully a someone has corrected the faulty = in some internal branch by now.
 If you are watching this bug, please also consider voting for VWR-1177.
Okies... not so much a fix and a tip/workaround...
The hidden interface is still usable while it's hidden... soo lowtech solution here... get a marker pen... mark the edge of your monitor... tear of the features menu that contains the interface hide option and move it to where the mark is. You now have an area of your sl screen that is marked as a place to hide/unhide the interface. Talia -
Your kludge brings to mind jokes about white-out on the screens, but it works! Thanks for the lowest of the low-tech patches. It also appears to me that CTRL SHIFT S (shortcut for Snapshots) makes UI re-appear when hidden. This could help sometimes.
This patch was nominated for inclusion in the sldev viewer by Opensource Obscure. The problem is that there's three different patches here, and it's not clear which ones are up for consideration, or which key combo will be used.
Question for OO: which patch file are you recommending, and what key combo does it implement? I think the right patch would be http://jira.secondlife.com/secure/attachment/20142/shortcutfix.patch
- see comment by Khyota Wulluf on 30/Oct/08 for details about key combos. Right now I can't apply it against http-texture recent sources, though. Given that this is already committed to maint-viewer-14, the happier solution would be getting that merged into trunk and rebranching http-texture from trunk/. We're doing an awful lot of cherry picking, and it's going to make for a difficult merge later on.
We're not going to branch from trunk for snowglobe before we get out a first release so, the choices are:
1- we live with that bug in that first snowglobe release. 2- we fix it. I can see creating a patch for snowglobe from OO "shortcutfix.patch" mentioned here above. I'd be worried having people use snowglobe for machinima production (too unstable...) so I'm voting "1" here. I'm willing to be overruled though by a popular vote and do a patch, even if it makes merges a pain as mentioned by Soft (and since I do them on snowglobe, I know what I'm taking about... I'm ok with 1 - This affects a small number of users, and I don't want to add merge pain
The real point is fixing it in the official viewer - right now I'm not sure about what exactly maint-viewer-14 is, but I hope it means "fixed in the next release cycle". Oh, there is a big issue with this patch: some keyboards like AZERTY keyboards (France, Belgium, ... ) and in some others don't have numbers in direct access.
Shortcuts in Alt/Shift/Control n won't be usable on those keyboards. Being able to map a shortcut to a physical keycode rather than on the character the keyboard driver says is printed on the key, would be the only universal fix (is it even possible?). Any updates?
As a quick solution I suggest: that is, edit indra/newview/llviewermenu.cpp find: modify to: |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 |
|
Bug
Fix Pending
Critical
Ctrl-Alt-F1 Hide/Show UI Does Not Work Correctly Under Linux
If you look at the debug menus, you'll see that the shortcut changed to Ctrl+Alt+F1